Hello Peter - my initial reaction would be to not blame the Drive just yet. The image and recovery procedures seem prone to failures. It I were you, i would bite the bullet and download the latest version of Windows 10 to a clean, formatted USB Stick. See 'Create Windows 10 Installation Media' at
www.microsoft.com/en-gb/software-download/windows10
The upside of this is that once you have the Windows 10 installation media done, you merely select that Drive when booting the MB1 (I think F12 is the necessary key), and Windows will deal with the new Samsung, assuming that is not a faulty drive.
The downside is that you have to reinstall all software from your backup which is a time consuming pain - but this is what I did here.
You will have a Microsoft Digital Licence stored on their server which obviates the need to acquire another Windows 10 Key (serial number). I recorded my Serial beforehand but found that I did not need it because Activation occurred automatically.
Erik.